Thread with 257 posts

jump to expanded post

it's been too long since i saw this, i had forgotten just how much character stuff happens inside other characters' arcs, not least of which for kanbaru and araragi's friendship and araragi and senjougahara's relationship

Open thread at this post

honestly if you go into monogatari with your irony-brain switched off and your barriers down it's really not that perverted of a show, but you really have to be able to put yourself in the character's shoes rather than being like Be Consumed Of Media And Get Opinion Of Thing

Open thread at this post

i keep being surprised at how Little happens in it relative to how i remembered it, and that's because what's changed is my relationship to the work and to media in general, the emphasis in my memories was all the work of a more squeamish past self in denial about liking the show

Open thread at this post

finished rewatching bakemonogatari

monogatari's still the greatest to ever do it and bake is a masterpiece

wish i could give post less superficial commentary but that's twitter as a medium for you, that's why i don't do play-by-plays any more

deeply meaningful, beautiful work

Open thread at this post

something surreal really in finally seeing the story of what happened with araragi koyomi and kiss-shot acerola-orion heart-under-blade and hanekawa tsubasa during golden week, the murky outlines of which have been in the background of my mind for a decade, in such visceral form

Open thread at this post

a thing that keeps taking me out of the experience a little is that the frame pacing is fucked whenever there's a panning shot or similar. i am surely used to what 24fps on a 60Hz monitor looks like by now, so i'm suspecting something's gone wrong elsewhere, oh well

Open thread at this post

some of kiss-shot and araragi's screams and whimpers and so on so far have been frightfully realistic, the VAs did an incredible job because they force me to confront the suffering whether i like it or not

Open thread at this post

「é˜ŋč‰¯ã€…æœ¨å…ˆčŧŠã€ãã‚Œã¯į‡ƒãˆã‚‹ãŒã‚´ãƒŸã˜ã‚ƒãĒã„ã€‚č…ãŖãĻはいãĻもåŋ…čρãĒį‰Šã ã€‚ã€

Open thread at this post

one of the beautiful things about japanese is that there are many, many ways a particular name you've heard might be spelled, so people have to explain the spelling with reference to compound nouns, and the particular choice of compounds says a lot about their personality

Open thread at this post

judging by how many times this has happened so far in bakemonogatari and nisemonogatari when someone introduces themselves, i think nisioisin particularly enjoys writing these. his character names are delightful. kanbaru suruga and kaiki deishuu's are personal favourites

Open thread at this post

i think calling kaiki deishuu a villain would not be unfair, but he's such an interesting one because he exists on neutral ground, he's not cartoonishly evil, he's a very mundane evil and the show lets him explain himself

Open thread at this post

completely unrelated thought: i'm still reeling from just how much, well, seeing kizumonogatari changes how bakemonogatari and nisemonogatari feel. i almost wonder if my "ideal watch order" would have someone watch bakemonogatari twice, but that seems... fanciful

Open thread at this post

phew, i've finally rewatched nisemonogatari

rewatching that was fairly tedious for me. i expect that once i'm done with (re)watching the whole series it'll still be the low point of it for me. but it's still good to have done it... better than it existing to me as pure osmosis

Open thread at this post

it's really making me regret my screenshot-hoarding habit, if you have looked over screenshots of things you've seen, rather than actually rewatching them, even if unintentionally, it distorts your memory

Open thread at this post

apparently i finished watching nisemonogatari the first time sometime in 2016, the same year that i saw bakemonogatari. it was then a long, long time until i seriously picked up the series again. perhaps nisemonogatari was responsible for me losing interest for so long. tragic

Open thread at this post

you know i think my nuclear take might be that the sex scenes in subahibi are a lot more contextually palatable than araragi's constant antics in monogatari but they'd crucify me for saying that

Open thread at this post

wait was the scene where araragi finds out hanekawa's wound on her face is from her father hitting her adapted twice?? this definitely came up in kizu and now it's in neko kuro, but maybe the former was a flashback, but i don't feel like it was...

Open thread at this post

in these last two months i have also rewatched suruga monkey again at least twice. in a sense that's why i need to rewatch hana, otherwise i'm stuck in the past etc. i rewatched because i'm kanbaru. if it wasn't obvious, the koimonogatari rewatch was for senjougahara-senpai.

Open thread at this post

ah, nekomonogatari shiro begins with hanekawa talking about her not conceptualising her own name as belonging to her; how she's not a god to be put on a pedestal; how she's “cat, tiger, and only human”; and then: “Now, the time has come to awaken from this nightmare.”

â€Ļfamiliar

Open thread at this post

ã€Œįœ ã‚Šå§Ģはね įŽ‹å­ãŽã‚­ã‚šã‚’
åž…ãŖãĻいるだけでは だめだと」

“it wouldn't do for the sleeping beauty to just lie there waiting for her prince's kiss”

oh goddamnit they're gonna kill us

Open thread at this post

senjougahara and hanekawa are a little bitâ€Ļ you knowâ€Ļ

(i do remark upon this at some point to araragi and he's totally oblivious, somehow)

Open thread at this post

jesus christ i had completely forgotten the

“don't get the wrong idea, i'm not like kanbaru. [rot13]nyy v jnag vf gb frr lbh anxrq”

should i feel honoured or insulted? senjougahara-senpai, what did you mean by thisâ€Ļ

Open thread at this post

god there's a whole bit in nekomonogatari shiro episode 2 where the tiger tells black hanekawa (cat) that “oddities' [æ€Ēį•°] characteristics are not something that can be suppressed. the people who see us reap what they sow. your master saw me. nothing else matters”

â€Ļyea

Open thread at this post

this scene from nekomonogatari shiro episode 2, where senjougahara figures out hanekawa has no taste in a broad sense, is very necessary watching.

“Don't you think having things you hate is just as important as having things you like?”

Open thread at this post

good lord, the scene at the start of the following episode, where senjougahara explains that hanekawa is different from araragi in that she acts as if she doesn't even realise being goodhearted is dangerous, is even worse. “you're too white[hearted]”.

Open thread at this post

oh right the OP is called 「chocolate insomnia」. it's funny because we're resuming the rewatch right now to help us sleep. our brain has been too nerded-out and it's bad because we're presently ill and we'll drive ourselves mad with strange thinking loops like this.

Open thread at this post

this little clip from Nekomonogatari Shiro ep3 is one of the most plural things we've ever seen. we do not just mean the obvious Black (cat) Hanekawa thing. the entire sequence, including the way Shinobu shows up

Open thread at this post

[Nekomonogatari Shiro episode 4]

Araragi's mom: [~“don't get used to staying here OK, we can't be your family”]

Hanekawa: Sorry I made you worry. But my family circumstances aren't as complicated as you think. There's just a little discord right now. That's all.

Araragi's mom:

Open thread at this post

i feel somehow obligated to post a clip of most of the opening scene of Kabukimonogatari, where Ougi discusses the meaning of stop lights with Araragi, as a metaphor for how people aren't sufficiently cynical about the world

Open thread at this post

the MTBB full-season batch of monogatari is good in many ways but man we do not like some of these translation choices. i think a lot of it is commie's fault. like come on you can't turn “shota koyomi” into “little koyomi” you're removing the flavour in what shinobu actually said

Open thread at this post

we do respect in theory the concept of trying to avoid sounding like a weeb when translating, but the problem with that is that the monogatari series is fundamentally otaku media, the characters constantly make otaku culture references, they should sound like weebs you know!

Open thread at this post

also we prefer “aberration” as a translation of æ€Ēį•° [kaii] over “oddity”, but we are really nitpicking here, the translation is overall very very good, you know

Open thread at this post

ougi shows up

oh man that voice. we've missed that voice

and she and somehow knows nadeko's name, also also about hachikuji, and we happen to know she also has access to things araragi owns

oh is he. is she. is it. are they. is ougi like. you know

Open thread at this post

if koimonogatari was “well, it doesn't feel like a story about the supernatural, it feels like a story about mental illness”, otorimonogatari (which we ought to have rewatched first) is â€Ļâ€Ļâ€Ļ uncomfortably even moreso

Open thread at this post

I've been marathoning Hanamonogatari in the small hours of this morning because I've been needing it. Your girl isâ€Ļ well, whether she's Kanbaru Suruga そぎもぎ, or just hikari the kinnieâ€Ļ definitely someone with a special relationship to this anime series, to put it one way.

Open thread at this post

this is a much more comforting watch this time (we watched hanamonogatari for the first time 3.5 years ago). it feels like home in a way we were still somewhat trying to resist at that time

Open thread at this post

I'm going to let myself have a Hanamonogatari layout and profile pic for a bitâ€Ļ It'll be fun to not be faceless on Twitter for a while again, but it will of course stop being fun the moment it's not me talking, so I expect we'll have to swap pfp again laterâ€Ļ

Open thread at this post

A close friend remarked to us that Hanamonogatari is remarkably lonely compared to the rest of the series, and I think that's a big part of why it's so affecting for us. That kind of lonely, brooding solitude is â€Ļ something that feels intrinsic to me (as Kanbaru Suruga).

Open thread at this post

finished Onimonogatari, and with that, we've finally rewatched all of Second Season

phew

we were not intending our bake/nise/neko + second season rewatch (+watching kizu for the first time) to take five months

but you know, Otorimonogatari Suruga Edition happened in the middle

Open thread at this post

we've reached the part of our “monogatari series rewatch and catchup” where we've rewatched everything we had seen before, so it's finally time for new content

according to the directory structure of these mkv files that fell off the back of a truck, next is “tsukimonogatari”

Open thread at this post

and so after nearly ten years of knowing about the monogatari series and at least half of that time being uhh profoundly influenced by it, we are finally going to watch the “final season” that aired checks notes roughly when we started watching bakemonogatari the first time ^^;

Open thread at this post

koyomimonogatari is interesting in how it starts as pointless little stories, more or less slice-of-life in a way, and then at the end it's back to occult research club (or whatever it's called) shenanigans again? was this nisoisin trying to hook people for the next novel or

Open thread at this post

our habitual curiosity about what japanese words characters are actually saying is constantly revealing just how much is lost by translating monogatari into english. for example, araragi uses an idiom coming from kabuki (čŒļį•Ē) and tadatsuru responds another in kind (十å…Ģį•Ē)

Open thread at this post

nisioisin is the kind of writer who seemingly has an autistic fixation on writing itself, everything is wordplay, all the timeâ€Ļ it's not like this with a more “normal” series

Open thread at this post

and with that, it's finally over. we've finished watching monogatari, and only... 6.5 years late. the series that's been haunting us for an entire decade now, the series that I can't convey myself without reference to...

man.

(yes we know about off&monster season. another time)

Open thread at this post